191 // Bureaucracy In Welfare Is Annoying

Facebook | Twitter | Youtube | Instagram | Bloglovin’

The first challenge of bureaucracy is learning how to spell it, whilst spelling has never been a strong point, bureaucracy remains a particular thorn in my side. The fact I’ve had 4 attempts to spell it in the last two sentences is a testament to that fact. The second major problem with bureaucracy is that it couldn’t be anymore perfectly designed to be exactly the most annoying thing I ever have to deal with.

To clarify, since I arrived in Ireland I have been looking for work and to cover costs in the mean time I have applied for ‘Job Seekers Allowance’. This is a weekly payment from the Government of around €180 to cover costs of living. Needless to say the bureaucracy involved is turning this into an extremely long and frustrating process.

In bureaucracy’s defence, it does serve a purpose – to annoy every human on planet earth.

It only* exists to weed out dishonesty and fraud. So in order to do that there must be more checks, more paper work, more proof, proof, proof that you are absolutely entitled to what you are applying for. Or at least any austerity driven Government will tell you that is the case.

From the Government’s point of view, welfare payments are a cost to society, the logic being that if more people claim through welfare the more it will cost them. Therefore it is in their interest to reduce this cost. The thing which is often forgotten though, is that it is not them, it is us. The Government is run by officials elected by us to run the country for us – it is not a business.

Baring this in mind it is worth remembering the basis of the welfare payment system, and to not forget its success. It was essentially born in Germany as a direct riposte to The Great Depression in the 1920s and 30s. During that period there was no safety net and essentially no support from Governments at all, as a result thousands were left homeless, physical health declined dramatically, mental health declined dramatically, malnutrition was rife. and it caused a significant number of deaths – sounds like a real cost to me! In the following 80 years since welfare’s introduction it has cut all of these issues out of society dramatically, including providing a much more stable economy, which has reduced the negative effects of the business cycle (recessions) by around half. So in short, it is a very big benefit.

This is because people who lose work can still afford to eat, they can still afford to pay their rent or mortgage, they can still study, they can still have access to healthcare and they are relieved of a significant mental stress, which allows them to look for work. The workforce and society at a large therefore is fitter, healthier, happier, more educated and safer.

The downsides, which are disproportionately presented in the media, are that some people take advantage of the system, and have no intention of working. Don’t get me wrong here, that is legitimate fraud – a crime, and that is ultimately why these long drawn out annoying bureaucratic system are in place, to stop exactly that.

Historically speaking though people are treated with suspicion after a crime has been committed, not before. A bureaucratic system, like this one though, seems to be designed to catch criminals before they have committed a crime. That means it must treat everyone as a suspect. So, for a system which was designed to support, it has somehow evolved into a system that treats everyone with suspicion and disdain. All because Governments are not actually trying to stop fraud, they’re trying to reduce cost. That is a subtle, but big difference.

If you want to stop fraud you increase funding into things like whatever the fancy name for the fraud police is – but don’t get me started on police funding.

The results of that are things like the ‘Fit For Work’ initiative drawn up by the British Government. Under this initiative officials will visit your home and decide whether you are fit for work or not – even if it has already been proven that you were not previously fit enough. If you are declared fit your welfare payments will be stopped/reduced and you must legally find work.

Now, according to official figures it takes, on average, 10 weeks to find a job in the UK, it is strange then that 4,000 people who were declared ‘fit for work’ by the Government died within 6 weeks of that declaration. Very fit indeed, and only 4 weeks shy of finding a job – so close!

For me visiting the Government offices today there was no care in their approach, I was met with what felt like cynicism and suspicion. But for me, a person with no physical disabilities and with a strong education behind me it is just annoying and disheartening – not a big deal; I fill out more papers, send in more documents and see what happens – all will be well. For others though, others who are now having to go further and further to prove how disabled they are, or how unfit they are to work shows how uncaring we have become. We care more about potential fraud than potential life saving care.

Whilst diligence is always recommended, there has to be a line, once that line is crossed it is up to the police or other relevant authorities to catch criminals, treating those most desperate in society as potential criminals before they’ve even taken a penny is counter productive.  Not to mention, very, very, very, very annoying (for me*).

Paul Green

*Sarcasm

*Boo-hoo

Read more, it’s good for you.

About Me

190 // Proof Evolution Is Real

166 // Schools Know Nothing

22 Comments

  1. helentastic67

    Yeah, so. I confess I couldn’t read all the way through as I have felt your pain………it is a full time job being unemployed and easier to find a job. All government welfare agencies seem to treat us like we have another option of funding. Yet they are geared to not help you. It’s why we pay tax after all but they don’t advertise their services. It’s to dis courage you using welfare. Cheers,H

    Liked by 1 person

  2. anonymousmaussite

    I work within this system. It is sadly shambolic, and unfortunately the fight is to convince the staff working there that can see people getting more in benefit payments than they earn that we are all part of the same exploited class. The State is no longer there to support its citizens, and the declining state of public services is testament to that. One slight factual error, is that most people have to visit medical centres for their assessments, they don’t usually get visited. That would be too much to expect unfortunately. Cheers for writing this. Solidarity, and I hope you are sorted soon. Not all DWP workers are unfeeling scum by the way. We are mostly as depressed by the system as those that use it, and by the way, the sickness policy for staff is also repressive. 7 days allowed per rolling year before you are on the path to dismissal. Cheers.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. anonymousmaussite

        i need to be anonymous or i’ll get my arse fired. that being said, I’m happy to offer opinion, and I’m active in the Trade Union too which puts me further to the left than most. If you would accept a class conscious agenda that seeks to unite and not divide I’m always happy to connect buddy.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. ibizagoldgirl

    Ugh! I had this battle in the UK after a surgery and prolonged recovery. I did understand that I had recently been living it up as a student squandering money on discounted topshop and cheap cider but I now faced a different reality, one where I was pained, scarred, mentally battered and bed-bound – I wasn’t making it up, I just wanted some of my freaking tax back!!
    Oh the joys! Annoying is not the word.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. nicholasjlennox

    It is sadly shambolic, and unfortunately the fight is to convince the staff working there that can see people getting more in benefit payments than they earn that we are all part of the same exploited class. […] 191 // Bureaucracy In Welfare Is Annoying […]

    Like

  5. ckj2612

    The main pride we all had previously was our welfare state and our NHS, to which both are being destroyed. The minimum wage hasn’t went up while our MP’s has, we still have zero hour controls and unprofessional staff to stipulate whether we are fit to work or not. It’s turned into as I say a shambles and disgrace we have all paid into the system x

    Liked by 1 person

  6. lilesosanna

    That describes exactly what it is like end to end dealing with the Department of Social Protection, we are all criminals, cheats and scroungers and out Taoiseach supports that view.
    Hope you get a job before you are invited to the mandatory JobPath, its worse than spelling bureaucracy.

    Like

What did you make of that then?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s